Generally we think that cooling tower is Heat transfer equipment, but the actual thing is cooling tower is work on mass transfer and result is Heat transfer.
As we know Cooling towers are a very important part of many chemical plants.
The primary task of a cooling tower is to reject heat into the atmosphere.
They represent a relatively inexpensive and dependable means of removing low-grade heat from cooling water.
Hot water from heat exchangers is sent to the cooling tower. The water exits the cooling tower and is sent back to the exchangers or to other units for further cooling.
Some of the Applications are listed below..
- Oil refineries,
- Petrochemical industries
- Chemical Industries,
- Thermal Power plans,
- HVAC system for cooling buildings...
Working Principle:
Humidification Operation: This operation is concerned with the interphase transfer of mass and of energy which result when a gas is brought into contact with a pure liquid in which it is essentially insoluble.
Hear air is brought into contact with Water which is insoluble in air.
The matter transferred between phases in such cases is the substance constituting the liquid phase, which either vaporizes or condenses.
Reference: Google Images |
Mass transfer is only feasible when gas is unsaturated with vapor.
The hot water is usually caused by air conditioning condensers or other industrial processes. That water is pumped through pipes directly into the cooling tower. Cooling tower nozzles are used to spray the water onto to the “fill media”, which slows the water flow down and exposes the maximum amount of water surface area possible for the best air-water contact. The water is exposed to air as it flows throughout the cooling tower. The air is being pulled by an motor-driven electric “cooling tower fan”.
When the air and water come together, a small volume of water evaporates, creating an action of cooling. The colder water gets pumped back to the process/equipment that absorbs heat or the condenser. It repeats the loop over and over again to constantly cool down the heated equipment or condenser.
Types of Cooling Towers:
Comparison between Natural and Forced Cooling Tower
PARTICULARS
|
NATURAL OR FANLESS COOLING TOWER
|
FORCED OR FAN OPERATED COOLING
TOWER
|
Design
|
To work out evaporation required and
quantity of air required for this evaporation
|
Same
|
Air draft
|
Created with nozzles. Numbers of
nozzles are worked out.
|
Created with fan. Size of fan is
worked out.
|
Evaporation losses
|
Will depend on wet bulb temp. and
delta ‘T’
|
Will depend on wet bulb temp. and
delta ‘T’
|
Drift losses
|
Controlled by overlapping louvers
|
Drift eliminators used, consumes
more power
|
Approach
|
Up to 3-4 0 C
Steady all the time.
|
Can be less than 3 oC.
Increases as fills breaks and chokes
|
Range
|
Can be designed as per requirement
or higher range two towers in series to be installed
|
Can be designed as per requirement
For higher range two towers in series to be installed
|
Capacity (Flow rate)
|
Can be designed for any capacity.
Higher capacity to be split in two or more Numbers of modules.
|
Can be designed for any capacity.
For higher capacity to be split in two or more numbers of cells
|
Maintenance
|
No moving parts No
breakdown maintenance No stoppage of cooling tower so long as
circulation pump is running
|
Possibility of breakdown of
bearings, fan, gear, motor, fills, etc. Cooling tower to be stopped for
repairing Breakdown and maintenance can’t be avoided.
|
Spare parts
|
No spares required few
nozzles can be kept Nozzles can be changed without stopping cooling tower.
|
Require spares for drive and fills
Have to depend on supplier
|
Stand by cooling tower
|
Even for continuous operation stand
by cooling tower not required
|
For continuous operation stand by
cooling tower is required to take care against breakdown
|
Cost and investment
|
Initial cost is less. No investment
for stand by cooling tower. Thus two ways saving in investment.
|
Higher initial cost.
Cost of stand by
cooling tower. So added initial investment.
|
Power consumption
|
No power consumption. Equivalent
power available for other critical process equipment
|
Power is a must at the cost of
other critical process equipment.
|
Payback period
|
No power consumption. No power
bill. Payback period is almost one year.
|
No payback period On the contrary
there is running expense on power bill
|
Power failure
|
In case of power failure only
circulation pump is to be run on D G.
|
In case of power failure D G is to
be unnecessarily loaded for fan motor.
|
Excellent comparison table..
ReplyDeleteNice content
This post is a great resource. I appreciate the effort you put into researching and writing it.
ReplyDelete